Critique

One pencil to rule them all.

You send me a shot. I watch it the way an audience will, then draw over it, frame by frame, and talk you through what I see.

What a critique is

A recorded draw-over of your shot. First what's working, then the three things that will make the biggest difference, in order. Not a list of everything wrong. The few notes that move the shot furthest.

Why it matters

Animation is learned by failing to reproduce what you see, again and again, until the failure narrows. A critique narrows it faster.

After a hundred plays, your own eye has learned to forgive your shot. A trained eye hasn't. It sees the weight that isn't landing, the pose that isn't reading, the moment the character stops thinking.

Why the pencil is mighty

Words describe a problem. A drawing shows the fix. "Lead with the hips" is a sentence you have to translate. An arc drawn through the hips, on your own frame, at your own timing, is something you can see.

And it doesn't stay in a video you watch once. The Mighty Pencil sends the drawings back onto your own timeline, in Maya, Moho, After Effects or Harmony, so each note sits on the frame it belongs to while you fix it.

Jack's War on Symmetry

A straight, symmetrical line is a dead line. Life is asymmetrical and curvaceous.

How it works

  1. 1Upload your shot

    An MP4 straight out of your program. Up to ten seconds works best.

  2. 2I draw over it

    Frame by frame, with written notes where words help.

  3. 3You get it back

    A review video anyone can watch, plus the drawings for your program.

Free while we build the library

Critiques are free for now. In return, if you agree, your shot and its critique may appear on the Videos page so other animators can learn from it.